Finding Your Dog’s Perfect Toy

Some are chewers; some are chasers. Some parade theirs around like Olympic gold while others bury or hide in the cushions. Whatever your dog’s play style, finding long-lasting toys that keep them engaged can be an expensive process of trial and error. The good news is mess, extra expense, and emergency vet trips can all be avoided by following a few simple tips for choosing the perfect playthings for your furry friend.

Size

Toys, just like crates, leashes, and food, should be in proportion to your dog. Something too small poses a choking hazard, and something too large will be too heavy or cumbersome for them to enjoy. It should be small enough they can carry it, but big enough that it won’t fit in the back of their mouth. Always look for size guides on a prospective toy’s packaging or check the brand’s website for size recommendations.

Shape

Short-nosed breeds like pugs may struggle with getting their mouths around chunkier toys whereas long-muzzled breeds can put almost anything between their jaws. Make sure your dog’s toy isn’t a shape they can get their faces or limbs stuck in. Of course, there also should not be any sharp edges or points on which they could hurt themselves.

You can always opt for toys that do some work for you, too. Not only are there toys that will dispense treats, you can also find ones that clean your dog’s teeth, talk to them, and even take their picture!

Material

Choosing the right material is one of the most important factors in your dog’s health, safety, and enjoyment in a toy. The range of options on the market is vast. Some are tried and true while others pose danger.

Plush toys may be cuddly and comforting, but pose risks with their stuffing, squeakers, shred-prone cloth, synthetic dyes, buttons, ribbons, and other decorations a dog can tear off and ingest. They also collect more dirt and germs than most other toys. Plush toys are great options for elderly dogs and dogs with tooth sensitivities but should generally be kept out of reach when not supervised.

For similar reasons, beware of squeaky toys. Determined pups may try tearing the squeakers out and choke or chew the plastic into sharp pieces.

Balls come in countless variations, so you might consider getting your dog a assortment to try. Some light up, which is fun for outdoor games of fetch in the evenings. Some are motorized to give your dog an extra challenge. Some even dispense treats the longer your dog plays with it. But it doesn’t need any special feature to keep your pup busy. The common tennis ball is a classic choice. Just make sure your dog doesn’t pull off or eat the fuzz as it contributes to tooth decay and mouth pain. It’s best to give your dog tennis court grade balls. Knock-off versions have a weak seam between two plastic halves on the inside which is easily breakable. Once cracked, a dog can tear it apart and ingest the pieces. Standard regulation tennis balls can withstand more use and will keep your dog happy much longer.

Hardness is another important criterion when looking for the right material.

If a toy doesn’t have a little bit of give when you press a fingernail into it, it’s too hard for your dog’s teeth. Look for firm rubber that can withstand both big and little teeth and can’t be bitten or chewed off into little pieces.

Consider any coatings, additives, or dyes. Chemicals added for scent, flavor, or color may cause digestive issues or allergic reactions. Play it safe and do a little research before Fido gets his paws on it.

Dog’s Age

Just like people, dogs’ interests and needs change with age. Specially designed teething toys are great for puppies, but you can also freeze regular rubber toys for the same effect. For older dogs that aren’t as physically active, look for more mentally engaging options like puzzle toys or differently textured chew toys.

Maintenance

Rotating your dog’s toys helps keep their interest, slows wear and tear, and gives you the chance to clean them properly. Many plush toys are machine washable and dryer safe, and can be thrown in with regular laundry. For plastic toys, mild non-toxic dish soap with water works great. Just be sure all toys dry completely in order to prevent mold.

The general rule when shopping for dog toys is you get what you pay for. Cheap toys usually don’t last and tend to be made of poor and even harmful materials. Low-quality, mass-produced items typically haven’t undergone testing or safety checks, so beware of giving your dog anything you suspect could be harmful. It’s less expensive and safer for your dog in the long run to invest in a well-made toy that will last for many years of enjoyment.

What are your dog’s favorite play things? Keep an eye out for our top-rated recommendations list coming out soon!